4206909 - adding Z_SYNC_FLUSH support to deflaters
Alan.Bateman at Sun.COM
Fri Sep 11 02:42:13 PDT 2009
Xueming Shen wrote:
> I think we have enough discussion on this topic, it's time to make a
> final decision. Seems like we are all happy on the
> changes in Deflater and new DOS.flush(mode), the only difference is
> whether or not we should change the existing
> behavior of DOS.flush() should use Z_SYNC_FLUSH by default.
> Brandon is very firm on the "yes" side, strongly believe this is a MUST.
> Martin is on the fence, leaning towards "yes"
> Sherman is on the "no" side
> So if there is no other vote coming with strong opinion, your vote
> will be important:-) Are you also leaning to "yes"
> or "strongly" suggesting a yes? I need strong "yes" to change my mind.
This is tough call. It is clearly desirable to change flush() to work
the way that developers expect. On the other hand there is always risk
with changing long-standing behavior. The risk here is probably low but
it's impossible to quantify. Martin makes a good observation that it may
cause problems for code that wraps the stream with an auto-flushing
PrintStream or PrintWriter. You also made a good observation that just
changing the number of bytes written could cause breakage (in some
fragile environment) - we just don't know! So on balance, I think you
are probably right to take the conservative line on this one.
I know you've had enough discussion on this but I wonder if you might be
open to considering new constructors for DeflaterOutputStream (and maybe
GZIPOutputStream) as an alternative to the flush(int) method. This might
fit better with this API, in particular for cases where the intended
usage is known. It could be as simple as a "boolean syncFlush" parameter
to indicate how uncompressed buffered bytes are handled when flushing
(default to false for existing constructors so existing behavior
preserved). The boolean parameter is just an opening bid - clearly
there are alternatives. The point is that it makes it easy and more
obvious as how to get a DeflaterOutputStream suitable for interactive cases.
More information about the core-libs-dev